December 31, 2025
With over 70 independently-owned restaurants, along with a beautiful backdrop, it’s no wonder couples flock here to pop the question, wed, celebrate milestones and simply enjoy reconnecting. Here are our suggestions, in no particular order, of the most romantic restaurants on Amelia Island.
Fresh, authentic Italian-style cuisine featuring pasta, pizza, seafood, and an extensive beer and wine list. “Years of experience culminated with a passion for food, wine and love for people!” Located in Palmetto Walk Shopping Plaza.
4828 First Coast Hwy
Ciao’s casual yet elegant dining room is warm and inviting (Owner, Luca will greet you with a big smile) incorporating traditional and contemporary Italian fare, always with the freshest and finest ingredients.
614 Centre Street
Lagniappe combines the traditions of the French Creole with unique twists on Southern culinary staples using only the freshest local ingredients. Dine inside or outside on the patio. Located on the south end of Amelia Island.
4810 First Coast Hwy
Located at Omni Amelia Island Resort, dinner at Bob’s isn’t just a meal, it’s an experience with a lively atmosphere and simple elegance. Serving prime steaks, chops and seafood by a friendly staff.
80 Amelia Village Circle
The Salt dining experience features simple ingredients from the earth and sea, properly seasoned, artfully prepared and served in a contemporary coastal setting. Reserve the chef’s table for an unforgettable culinary experience at the Ritz-Carlton, Amelia Island.
4750 Amelia Island Pkwy
The made-from-scratch menu is small by design to focus on a handful of exquisite dishes each season. At Burlingame, we realize that dining out is about more than just the food on the plate.
20 S 5th Street
A cozy, casual restaurant featuring banquet seating, a covered outdoor patio, private dining room, full bar, and extensive wine selection. Step into southern refinement with a bend.
1408 Lewis Street
For a special evening, discover this elegant, darkly-lit and upscale fine dining establishment specializing in steak and seafood with an extensive wine list. Visit the lounge for unique cocktails.
802 Ash Street
Flavors from Spain and Portugal make this a local favorite. Enjoy each other’s company (and the paella) in the cozy main dining room, on the enclosed patio or in the lush outdoor garden.
22 S 4th Street
Nestled in a 1906 cottage in the heart of historic downtown, Indigo promises an elevated dining experience of southern coastal cuisine and elegance.
20 S 2nd Street
View a complete list of Amelia Island dining options.
On Amelia Island, romance doesn’t start with dinner reservations. It literally begins the moment you wake up. The place you stay can set the tone for your entire getaway – […]
Get ready to dig in! Amelia Island Restaurant Week is just around the corner (January 16 – 25, 2026), and your chance to taste the best dishes from some of […]
If you’re strolling through downtown Fernandina Beach, a stop at Salty Pelican Bar & Grill is always a good idea. It’s a prime waterfront spot overlooking the Amelia River with […]
As we find ourselves in the final stretch of the year, there’s no better time than now to reflect on your 2025 bucket/resolution list and make those dreams a reality. […]
Winter settles gently over Amelia Island, trading the hustle and bustle of summer for a quieter kind of magic. With mild temperatures, wide-open beaches, and a cozy historic downtown draped […]