September 16, 2026
Amelia Island has some great spots to get your pumpkin spice fix with flavored coffees, shakes, and delectable bakery treats.
From locally brewed lattes to pumpkin cheesecake and warm-from-the-oven goodies, let’s take a tour of a few sweet spots to add to your fall foodie list.
Housed under the same roof as Mocama Beer Company, Mocama Coffee is a favorite stop for locally crafted coffee in a cool, laid-back setting. Espresso, cold brew, pour-overs, and specialty drinks make it an easy place to get your caffeine fix. Keep an eye out for seasonal creations as fall rolls in—they’ve been known to have a little fun with pumpkin and other autumn flavors.
Right in the heart of historic downtown, Amelia Island Coffee is practically made for a fall coffee break. Their menu includes hot and iced coffee drinks, espresso, chai, pastries, and other breakfast goodies—and pumpkin spice syrup is on the menu. Order it in a latte, grab a cinnamon roll or scone, and settle in before heading back out to explore Centre Street.
Fall is a pretty good excuse to eat cheesecake, right? Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop is known for its made-from-scratch cakes, cupcakes, cookies, pies, pastries, and plenty of other temptations. When autumn arrives, watch for seasonal favorites such as pumpkin cheesecake and other spiced creations. One look inside the pastry case and your plans to “just browse” may quickly disappear.
One of the newer additions to Amelia Island’s sweet scene, A Will and A Whisk Bakery is a retro-inspired, small-batch bakery where the menu changes regularly. Gooey cinnamon rolls, scones, and brown butter sea salt chocolate chip cookies are among the favorites, along with an ever-changing lineup of cakes, cookies, and pastries. Fall has already inspired pumpkin rolls and festive seasonal cookies here, so it’s definitely worth checking out what’s fresh from the oven.
Cozy up with a taste of fall at Kismet Coffee, a locally owned coffee shop on the south end of Amelia Island where quality coffee and housemade flavors take center stage. Their fall menu brings plenty of autumn inspiration, with creations like the Pumpkin Loaf Latte, Blackberry Cobbler Matcha, and Caramelized Orange Milk Tea. Pair your drink with avocado toast or a baked good, settle into the cozy space, and consider your fall coffee craving officially handled.
Gluten-free doesn’t mean missing out on the good stuff. Thirteen is a dedicated gluten-free dessert bar serving cakes, cupcakes, cookies, cheesecakes, and more. Pumpkin Bourbon Cheesecake and Caramel Apple Cheesecake have both made appearances on seasonal menus, making this little Beech Street sweet spot especially tempting when fall cravings strike.
Want to create your own fall masterpiece? Vintage Donuts on Centre Street specializes in warm, made-to-order cake donuts customized with your choice of icing, toppings and drizzle. Pumpkin icing has been among the shop’s fall offerings, and when you start adding flavors like maple, caramel, cinnamon and Biscoff to the mix, things can get deliciously out of hand.
Need your pumpkin fix to go? 7 Brew Coffee makes it easy with its drive-thru location and huge selection of customizable coffee drinks, teas, smoothies, and more. Check out the seasonal menu for fall flavors like Caramel Apple Pie Macchiato or Pumpkin Roll Shake, or create your own autumn-inspired combination for a quick pick-me-up before your next island adventure.
For a lighter take on fall flavor, stop by Amelia Fresh Cafe inside Amelia Organic Market. The organic eatery and coffee bar focuses on fresh ingredients and better-for-you options, so you can get a taste of the season without completely abandoning your healthy intentions. Look for seasonal drinks and treats alongside the cafe’s smoothies, juices, and wholesome menu favorites.
Holy Grounds Coffee House is a gathering spot where good coffee and community go hand in hand. Sip on a specialty latte or other coffee creation and pair it with a muffin, breakfast bread, danish, cookie, or slice of cheesecake. With its cozy, welcoming atmosphere, it’s an easy place to settle in and savor a little fall flavor before heading out to explore the island.
Who says you need chilly weather to celebrate autumn? On Amelia Island, fall tastes like pumpkin, cinnamon, caramel, and freshly brewed coffee – with maybe a little ocean breeze on the side.
Menus and seasonal flavors change, so consider that the perfect excuse to stop in and see what each shop is whipping up this fall. Your pumpkin spice fix is waiting!
Hispanic Heritage Month (September 15 – October 15) honors the history, culture, and contributions of American citizens with ancestors from Spain, Mexico, the Caribbean, and Central and South America. What […]
It’s officially football season! Here are our go-to island watering holes where you can cheer on your favorite team over brews and bites.
The perfect Labor Day Weekend begins and ends with the folks you love to spend time with and Amelia Island is ready to celebrate with you. The most important thing […]
Fall looks good on Amelia Island. The summer heat begins to ease a bit, mornings feel a little cooler, and suddenly spending the day outside sounds like a good idea. […]
This fall, Amelia Island’s calendar is jam-packed with opportunities to savor exquisite cuisine, immerse yourself in captivating dance performances, groove to world-class jazz, and enjoy family-friendly festivals. Here’s your guide […]