May 28, 2025
Avast ye! Amelia Island may be best known today for its laid-back elegance, pristine beaches, and charming downtown, but dig just a little beneath the sand and you’ll uncover a swashbuckling past filled with tales of pirates, privateers, and buried treasure. Some stories are steeped in legend, others grounded in truth—but all are part of what makes Amelia Island so uniquely captivating.
With its strategic location near the mouth of the St. Marys River and proximity to major shipping lanes, Amelia Island was once considered prime real estate for pirates and smugglers. It’s one of the only places in the United States to have flown eight different flags—often a sign of its turbulent history.
During the “Golden Age of Piracy” in the late 1600s and early 1700s, many believe Amelia Island served as a pirate hideout. Its marshy inlets, hidden coves, and easy access to the Atlantic made it the perfect place to lay low—or stash some stolen loot.
But was it really a pirate haven? Historians offer a cautious “yes.” While there’s no definitive proof that Amelia Island was a pirate headquarters per se, there is ample evidence that pirates passed through—and some even stayed.
No tale of piracy is complete without mentioning Edward Teach, better known as Blackbeard. Though most of his infamy stems from the Carolinas and Virginia, legends swirl that Blackbeard and his crew once anchored off Amelia Island, perhaps to resupply—or maybe to hide a bit of treasure. As with much of pirate lore, the line between fact and fiction is blurred, but the rumors persist.
Then there’s Luis Aury, a real-life privateer (and sometimes outright pirate) who, in 1817, claimed Amelia Island for Mexico—despite having no official authority to do so. Aury and his band of revolutionaries held Fernandina for a short time before being ousted by U.S. forces. His occupation is one of the better-documented pirate events in Amelia Island’s history.
Pirate spirit is alive and well in Fernandina Beach. Enter the Fernandina Beach Pirates Club, a lively group of locals who don full pirate regalia to bring history to life.
From participating in local parades and festivals (including the famous Isle of Eight Flags Shrimp Festival) to engaging with the community through charity work, the club celebrates the island’s adventurous past with humor, heart, and a bit of historical flair. Membership is open to all who embrace the pirate life—even landlubbers!
Don’t be surprised if you run into a pirate or two walking the streets of downtown Fernandina. Word has it, they are of the friendly sort though. Make sure to get a photo with them and tag us on instagram.
So, is there buried treasure still out there? No one’s telling—and that’s half the fun. Whether you’re hunting for doubloons or just soaking in the sun, Amelia Island offers a rare blend of natural beauty and legendary adventure.
The real pirates may be gone, but the magic of their myth remains. Visit these spots on Amelia Island and get in touch with your “piratical” side. We’ll see you scallywags soon!
If you’re dodging a rain shower or have had your share of sun for the day, take a look at these family-friendly treasures to discover indoors and on dry land.
Amelia Island’s historic bed & breakfast inns offer an enchanting blend of Southern charm and refined hospitality. Picture shady courtyards, rocking chairs on wide porches, and gardens brimming with blooms. […]
Beyond the sandy beaches, charming downtown, eclectic dining options, vast culture, and natural beauty, this barrier island holds some unique claims to fame. Amelia Island offers visitors a journey through […]
Amelia Island’s charming bed & breakfast inns are picture perfect in every way with secret gardens, shady courtyards, porch swings and rockers, fountains, stately architecture, and distinctive decor. Each award-winning property […]
To celebrate and honor Black History Month, here’s a look into some of the African-American history as well as events and ongoing experiences taking place on and around Amelia Island.