Natural Slice at Omni Amelia Island

Located within The Shops at Omni Amelia Island, this family-friendly, surf-inspired pizza joint serves a myriad of fresh ingredients on hand-tossed dough. Between specialty pizzas and create-your-own options, you are destined to find the perfect pizza just for you! Before you leave, grab frozen yogurt from Mellow Yellow, located within Natural Slice.

Dine-in, take-out and delivery available. Delivery available on the south end of Amelia Island. This includes addresses south of South Fletcher Avenue.

  • Key Details
  • Price Range: $
  • Meals: Lunch, Dinner


Trip Advisor Certificate Of Excellence 2019


tripadvisor logo
July 15, 2023

Cool spot

Stopped twice once to grab a beer and the next time I tried a slice of pizza as well. Seemed to be good quality just should have picked a different type. Was still fantastic just needed a little more meat. Drink selection was nice.

July 08, 2023

Delicious, good value

The pizza was delicious thin crust, perfect for quick reasonable meal with kids. I definitely recommend it.

June 02, 2023

What a waste of space!

Proof that the Omni can ruin everything. Been here for 30 years. Bad hotels can even mess up pizza. Actually pizza was marginally edible at best. Salads are a no-fly zone. Avoid if at all possible. Harris Teeter frozen pizzas are 100% better without the brainless stoner vibe and high cost.

June 17, 2022

Wouldn't Look at Documentation for Service Animal

I was excited to visit Natural Slice Pizza and Surf Shop today (6/17/2022). I came in with a service animal and was told I could not have him in this place of business. I offered documentation and explained that he is a registered service animal with full documentation and was told by the boy working there that "no animals are allowed". I let him know about the laws of the Americans with Disabilities Act and that my service animal had full documentation; He still said no. I have never experienced this before and spoke with two staff, a boy and a girl on the phone, they were of no assistance other than getting the manager to call me back after I have already written an email to my attorney to get in touch with this business. The girl on the phone refused to provide an email and just kept saying "the owner will call you. I know nothing about this". PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE train your staff about those with disabilities and the laws regarding service animals. I have never been denied anywhere, especially denied the ability to provide my documentation for him. My friends and family could not believe this happened. The manager was nice, but still, this was so after the fact that I was told I could not enter with a service animal. This is a violation of my rights. It was hurtful to not even be able to provide documentation but just told "no" like my service animal was a common pet. I will never return and/or suggest this place of business to anyone. Again, the manager is nice but the staff does not seem equiped to handle those of disabled conditions.

April 29, 2022

Good Pizza

I'm from NY so it wasn't the best ive ever had as they would proclaim on site, but it is good and fresh! Go early or late, otherwise you;d be waiting a while.