Stephanie's Sugar & Spice Cafe

503A Centre Street, Fernandina Beach, Florida 32034
904-277-9779   |   Visit Website

About Stephanie's Sugar & Spice Cafe

Stephanie's Sugar & Spice Cafe is about fresh foods and all that goes with them. It’s about coming to the table, fellowship and joy. Whether you want the perfect dessert or a knockout side dish for a dinner party at home or just a casual picnic on the beach, she has what you need to get you on your way.

Stephanie's Sugar & Spice Cafe offers an assortment of catering options for you, your office or wherever you may need a delicious meal. We can provide a whole meal for you or just a few parts to make coming to the table that much easier for you.

Casual Dining
blue marker

Historic District




Trip Advisor Logo
25 Reviews

Mar 26, 2022 by 20FANG16

So good to be back to a somewhat normal world... these cookies are beyond compare.

There is and has been only one place to get a great peanut butter cookie... and post covid... Stephanie's is back to doing what they do great... Peanut butter cookies... add a twist... everything...

Read Full Review >>


Oct 29, 2021 by Stephanie M

Amazing, delicious and wonderful!

Not only is the owner, Stephanie a sweet and amazing person, her items are wonderful! We stopped in to get a sweet treat and it was so worth it. The chocolate muffin was so tender, the chocolate chip...

Read Full Review >>


Sep 30, 2021 by 381tammyk

Wonderful treats

Stephanie’s apple tarts are THE BEST! Always delicious! The mixed berry tart is also very good! Her cookies are freshly made and consistently great! The chocolate croissant is also very good. As...

Read Full Review >>

See All Reviews Write A Review

Located just off the coast of northeast Florida, Amelia Island is easy to reach, but hard to forget. With 13 miles of beautiful beaches, abundant native wildlife, and pristine waters, this barrier island has long been a beloved destination for visitors and residents alike.